Your breaking news article of 3-16-11 is remarkably accurate with the exception of one important fact which puts my credibility and business in question.

It is true that Chief Allan McClain contracted my services in August of 2010 to conduct an impartial and independent internal affairs investigation of the incident involving then Lt. Craig Clausen.

At the conclusion of my investigation I submitted my report, which included neither a written nor verbal recommendation as to a final disposition.

My report contained the facts as were told to me by the complaining party, witnesses and investigating sheriff's deputies and their reports only.

I know you were quoting Chief Clausen's attorney, Matthew Pavone, for whom I have the highest regard, and it may have appeared to him that I recommended the matter be somehow rejected.

But the truth of the matter is that once I submitted my investigation report to Chief McClain I had no further contact or communication with him.

Until your article I had no knowledge of what Chief McClain or then-DA Hopkins decided to do with either the personnel or the criminal side of the matter.

 

Gary Hill is a private investigator and retired chief investigator for the Lake County District Attorney's Office. He lives in Lakeport, Calif.

Editor's note: The original article has had a statement added to it from Hill on not offering a recommendation in the matter. An update note also has been placed on the story.